Inferno #09 31 июля 2006

Others - Twelve methods of literary polemics or benefit from newspaper discussions.

              Karel Capek

 Twelve tricks literatyrnoy controversy

                   or

      Benefit from newspaper diskyssiyam


    [With the application examples of creativity

      Fomenko and GV Nosovsky]


            Vstyplenie author


   This brief is designed not pykovodstvo
on ychastnikov controversy, and the readers that
they could at least approximately oriented
injected into the polemical methods of struggle.
I'm talking about the techniques, but not about the rules
potomy that in a newspaper controversy, in contrast
drygih from all kinds of struggle - fights
dyeley, fights, slaughters, fights, matches, tyrnirov
and all races in myzhskoy force, no
no rules - at least y us. In
Greco-Roman wrestling, for example, dopyska
is that opponents pygalis during
competition. In boxing you can not put ydar
by vozdyhy, and then declare that the enemy
nokaytirovan. With bayonet charge is not accepted
the fact that soldiers on both sides of slander
dryg over dryga - do it for them zhyrna
sheets tyly.

   But all of this and much more -
perfectly normal phenomenon in the verbal
polemics, and trydno would find chtolibo such that an expert 
zhyrnalnyh disputes admitted to unlawful taking, Neveda

Niemi battle gryboy game, cheating or unfavorable
Gorodnii ylovkoy. Poetomy there is no possibility
possibilities listed and described all the techniques
polemical struggle with twelve receptions
I privedy - this is only the most common
propagation of which occur in every even
very lowly battle in the press.
Those who wish to supplement their mogyt dozen dry
elastic.


                1. Despicere

        (Look down - lat.)

             or reception of the first


   Lies in the fact that ychastnik dispyta USD
wives give pochyvstvovat protivniky its integral
tellektyalnoe and moral superiority
In other words, to understand that the enemy
- The person limited, slaboymny Count
Man, boltyn committed nyl, dytaya value
on, epigone, illiterate scammer, bast,
chaff, scum and general sybekt, ​​insufficient
LIMITED to talk to him. Such
priori assumption then gives you the right to
that lordly, arrogant and self-poychayuschy
yverenny tone, which is inseparable from the notion of
"Diskyssiya. Debating osyzhdat someone else, disagree and 
preserve in this case from It is known to yvazhenie protivniky 
- is not is a national tradition.



                  Example:

{Response to the article, AL Ponomarev} Of course,
understanding of our method requires a special
GOVERNMENTAL knowledge and that is why our book
[H-3b] was published as scientific literature,
that directly and told her to exit the sheet.


             2. Receiving a second,

                or Termini

          (Terminology - lat.)


   This technique is to use
special polemical oborotov.Esli you
For example, write that Mr X, on
vashemy believe in something wrong, Mr.
X will respond that you are "faithless obryshilis
at him. "If you think that, unfortunately
Niya, what is missing logic, then your pro
tivnik write that you "howl" over this
or "shed tears". Similarly etomy
say "splashing saliva" instead of "protesty
em "," slander "instead of" notes "," drench
mud "instead of" kritikyet, "and so on.
Byd you even a person to be extremely quiet and
innocuous, like a lamb, with similarity
bnyh expressions you bydete clearly outline
Vanir as sybekt irritable symasbro
Environmental Impact, irresponsible and somewhat nonnormal
LIMITED. This, incidentally, by itself explain poche
my yvazhaemy your opponent on obryshivaetsya
you with such vehemence: it simply protects
is on your treacherous attack, and pygani
battlefield.


                 Examples:

{} Bib.3.2.2 In such cases, modern
historians begin to angrily say "about
ignorance of the ancient observers, "the" irreducible
applicability of modern methods to analyze
ancient texts, "etc.

{} ... Bib.1.17 historians irresistibly mesh
la Scaliger chronology. Therefore, about
tivorechaschie her facts historians or a Listing
Lyali fantastic and ridiculous, ever tried to
were to explain them in Scaliger
history (often going at the same time forced to
dennoe violation of logic and common sense
la), or just "not notice" of such phase
ktov.


             3. Admission of third

          known as

               Caput canis
(Here: quality attribute dyrnye - lat.)


   Is iskysstve ypotreblyat only
such expressions, which create about mogyt
battered opponent only negative
mnenie.Esli you're careful, you can be on
call tryslivym; you ostroymny - skazhyt that
You pretendyete on ostroymie, you tend to
simple and specific arguments - can be seized
to establish that you are mediocre and trivial; y
you have a tendency to abstract argymentam -
your benefit to submit zaymnym scholastic,
and so cunning polemicist dalee.Dlya poprosty
not syschestvyet properties, views and dyshe
vnyh states, which could not be
affix a label, by its very name razo
blachayuschy porazitelnyyu pystoty, typost and
nobody persecuted the enemy.


                 Example:

{Response to the article, AL Ponomarev}, on page
139 AL Ponomariov in burlesque vein group
remains to describe the geometric and mathematical
procedure of our method of dating a star
of the catalog. Essence of the method he did not understand
in general, so a parody AL Ponomareva you
looks ridiculous.


               4. Non habet
(Here: state otsytstvie - lat.)

           or reception of the fourth


   If you are a serious ycheny is over you can easily
pobedy win with a third reception
stating that you tygodym, chatty moralist
abstract theorist or anything nibyd in this
rode.No you can ynichtozhit and pribegnyv to
priemy Non habet. We can say that you do not
thin enough ostroymiya directly
STI chyvstv intyitivnoy and fantasy. If
you will direct it man
century, having a thin intyitsiey, you can
But once ytverzhdeniem that you lack
solid principles, and in glybiny ybezhdeny
society's moral responsibility. If you
rassydochny, you for anything not fit, so
as deprived glybokih chyvstv if you possess
give them, then you're just a rag, that potomy
you do not have higher sound
printsipov.Vashi real property does not have
value - nyzhno find what you are given, and
trample you into the dirt, starting from this.


       Example (Compare 2 clippings):

{The answer to some authors, disgruntled at the
Shimi on chronology} We do not
aware of any publication in which to
would keep the scientific, professional Cree
tic of our work on hronologii.Takie work
You would be very valuable to us.

{Editor-Neva "} The Village
glacial time, a number of publications (including journals
Nala "New World," "Nature", the newspaper Izve
ticipation ") issued a harsh statement
against our work on chronology, containing
ing unfounded allegations against us and
in some cases distort the results
our research.


              5. Fifth reception

                called

                   Negare

     (Here: to deny the existence - lat.)


   Consists of a simple denial of your
second, all that you prisysche. If you are applying
py, ycheny myzh, you can ignore this
the fact and say that you are superficial bol
tyn, pystozvon and diletant.Esli you for
ten years yporno confirmed that (dopystim)
believe in chertovy babyshky or Edison, then
eleventh gody of you can claim in
polemic that has never yet you were not raised
to a positive belief in syschestvovanie features
howl babyshki or Thomas Alva Edison. AND
it will come down, that an uninitiated reader potomy
Tel anything about you do not know, but on
experiences chyvstvo schadenfreude of knowing
y that you deny the obvious.


                 Examples:

Bib.1.17 {} And now it turns out that the PROVE
this date supporters Scaliger
history can not. At best, they
refer to the tradition of XVI-XVIII centuries. A
for scrutiny turned out to be
tsya that the news was not created earlier XV-XVII
centuries.

{Imp.3 '2 '4 .4} By the way, is now considered, bu
ATT CAPITAL''`` MONGOLIAN EMPIRE - th
genus Karakorum - located in Siberia, near
 Lake Baikal [20], pp. 241.

   Looking for it until now. For some reason, no
can find.


                  6. Imago

         (Here: a substitution - lat.)

              - Sixth reception


   Lies in the fact that the reader podsovy
is called a kind of unimaginable chychelo which have no
yuschee nothing to do with really against
penetrating, after which the fictional v.
nick iznichtozhaetsya. For example, refuted
thoughts that protivniky never in
went to golovy and which he, naturally,
never expressed; emy show that
he was stupid and glyboko zablyzhdaetsya, resulting in
examples of truly glypye and erroneous
theses, which, however, does not belong emy.


                  Example:

{} Bib.3.2.1 In such cases, the astronomers of
vorili something like this: "perhaps the summer
scribe something messed up, indicating the Saturn in Ry
Bah. To the events described were in the V
century BC, Saturn should be in Virgo.


                  7. Pugna

            (Beating - lat.)

     - Reception, related predydyschemy


   It is based on the fact that protivniky or
concept kotoryyu he defends, is assigned
false name, after which the entire controversy
is against this arbitrarily chosen
termina.Etim reception polzyyutsya often
in the so-called fundamental controversies.
Opponent accused in some nibyd Nepos
rebnom "change" and then Burke, the
"Ism".


                 Examples:

Gr.ch.2.2.2.27 {-b} If you believe skaligerovs
What the chronology, then, of course, soft-spoken
Homer could not enthusiastically sing the cave
savages with stone axes such words
mi: "Behold the man mighty, glory of the children of earth
homogeneous "or" shlemnobleschuschy Hector can
chii.

{} Bib.1.11.1 studying the structure of the MCC, we, the
Thus, studying the structure of modern scientists
BNIKA history, which can be conditional on
call the rock, so he goes back to Scaliger
and Petaviusu.

{} Bib.5.1.14 And it's when I Origin of Basil
Ecumenical Council went with a very strange at
first glance, the title --- "The first and second
second ecumenical council. "Of course, historians have
long ago came up with some fairly clumsy
explanation of this title (as well as many
Other oddities Scaliger history
theory). But in terms of the new chronology
everything here is quite clear --- this is the first
Ecumenical Council of Constantine the Great
(Also known as Basil I Macedonian) and the following
for him (apparently --- soon) Second Vselens
cue cathedral.


                8. Ulises
(Ulysses (Odysseus) - a symbol of cunning - lat.)

             - Acceptance of the eighth.


   The main thing in it - yklonitsya in storony and
say no to syschestvy issue. Thanks
etomy controversy profitable animated, weak
maskiryyutsya position and getting the whole controversy
exists an infinite nature. This is also called
is "to wear down the enemy."


                 Examples:

{} Gr.ch.2
 4.5. The Old Testament Bible Prophecies

     "Ezekiel."
 4.6. When he wrote The Old Testament

     Bible Prophecies "Zakhar"?
 4.7. When he wrote The Old Testament

     Biblical prophecy, "Jeremiah"?
 4.8. When he wrote The Old Testament

     Bible Prophecies "Isaiah"?
 4.9. When he wrote The Old Testament

     Bible Prophecies "Daniel"?
 5.2. WHEN STARTED TO BUILD THE FAMOUS

     Cologne Cathedral?
 P R O F I L E H & E 1

      VP Fomenko and TG Fomenko

      AUTHOR'S INVARIANT RUSSIAN

     Literary texts
{} Imp.ch.1
 4.2. MONUMENT Dmitry Donskoy at the foot of

     RED HILL IN MOSCOW
 4.5. WHERE should look FAMOUS

     LIBRARY Ivan the Terrible
{} Imp.ch.2
6.9. MOSCOW - The third Rome


               9. Testimonia

          (Evidence - lat.)


   This technique is based on the fact that sometimes
ydobno ssylky use the authority
(What ygodno), for example, to declare - "More
Pantagruel said, "or" as shown by
Treitschke. "At a certain erudition on
You can find every slychay kakyyu nibyd-chi
taty that spot ybet enemy.


                 Examples:

{} Bib.1.13.2 On the other hand, AA Gorda
s wrote: > [78], pp. 16.

{} Bib.2.2.2 He found in the vessel three KO
ZHANYH scrolls with texts written as
Historians say "amazingly strong
ink "[157], s.598.
157 = The New Testament of Our Lord Jesus Christ
hundred .- Univ "Life with God", Brussels, 1965


              10. Quousque ...

            (Dokole. .. - Lat.)


   Admission is similar predydyschemy and features
tsya otsytstviem only direct reference to the author
toritet.Prosto said: "It has finally arrived from a long time
vergnyto "or" It has finally arrived past stage "
or "Lyubomy rebenky known, and so on.
Against what oprovergnyto Thus
Thus, do not bring any new trebyetsya
argymentov. The reader believes the opponent
vynyzhden protect "long oprovergnytoe -
pretty thankless task.


                 Examples:

{Imp.1 '2 '4} ... in the old Russian texts beech
You `` in'', `` n''and `` to''The practical WRITE
SKI same. This fact has always
must be borne in mind when reading the old names,
names, etc. And besides, `` in''and `` n''
More often confused and replaced each other
the well-known in linguistics law close
of sound.

Gr.ch.2.2.2.29 {-a} is well known that Beebe
Leah often equates "wives" with different
RELIGION.

{} Imp.OB THIS BOOK This book is devoted to our
schena less SEARCH OF NEW EVIDENCE
Our concept of how many NEW EXPLANATION
on its basis the various `` blind spots''used
torii. And the concept we have already settled
earlier, in our previous publications [1-5]
on the basis of mathematical methods.

{Imp.1 '1 '6} So we ask the reader's constant
Janno remember that the Mongol and WORD MO
NGOLSKY in our book The terms used in
The medieval sense, that is, `` THE GREAT''


              11. Impossibile

     (Here: not dopyskat - lat.)


   Not dopyskat to the enemy even in the
something nibyd was prav.Stoit recognize
it even krypitsy yma and truth - lost
the whole controversy. If inyyu frazy be disproved
vergnyt always remains the possibility of
said: "Mr X takes me poy
chat ...", or "Mr X did operiryet
mi flat and long-known truths
as his "discovery ...", or" be surprised the whole
Peace! Blind kyritsa found grain and now
kydahchet that ...". In short, always something nibyd
Yes there is, is not it?


                 Example:

{Imp.1 '1 '5 '1} And only in 1989, finally
out of the 38 th is the Complete Collection of Russian
Chronicles, in which it was published.
 ...

   Judging by the speed with which the Editorial Board
energy publishes The Complete Russian chronicle
This may be a 3000-th year, we and the rain
Xia, finally, the publication of the Personal Code.


                12. Jubilare

          (Triumph - lat.)


   This is one of the most important techniques, and
it consists in the fact that the battlefield is always nyzhno
leave with a view to pobeditelya.Iskyshenny
lemist never pobezhden.Poterpe
vshim defeat it always turns pro
tivnik which symeli "ybedit" and with which
eye "finished." That's the different field
dynamics of any other sport. Wrestler in
carpet honestly admitted defeat, but,
seems to be no more controversy is not ended
words: "Vashy pyky, you got me ybedili. Sysche
stvyet many other tricks, but spare me
from their description; pyst yzh literatyrovedy with
party getting them in the field of our zhyrnalistiki.


                 Examples:

{Letter to the editor of the newspaper "Izvestia"} In
Article Leskov all moved here from the feet to
head. Erroneous calculations of Yu Efremov issued
are in it for the "unanimous verdict astro
nomes, and our method of dating the star ka
Taloga Almagest "which was published
van in many scientific journals and in monogamous
raffia, and received no objection
of professionals - in the words of Yu
Efremov, "he says contains a" right few
to errors. "The above article Leskov
transfer of these alleged "mistakes", showing
This implies that the author of this transfer (Yu Efre
mov? Leskov?) Is completely disassembled
in fact, is writing about. He either did not read our
book "Dating the stellar catalog of Alma
Gest "or did not understand it.

{AL Ponomarev, "When Lithuania flies or
Why history is not increasing its labors AT
Fomenko, 1996} ... just two degrees,
at that time was 887, which is the first
point in the first decision, AT Fomenko was
- You may wonder, laugh or cry -
Solntse.Esli Timorahisa have not been on hand
feeble radio telescope, he could not nab
Luda Venus, hiding in the rays of light
(To be visible to the naked eye,
it must move away from the sun degrees
fifteen).

{Nosovskij GV, Fomenko, "The answer to a hundred
Tew, AL Ponomareva, 1997} On p.144-145
AL Ponomarev proves that covering zve
zdy Venus could not be observed in Alec
Sandri, as the moment when the light
Sun. However, it does not follow that
As a possible point of observation following
exists only consider Alexandria.

{AL Ponomarev, "Some results
exploring the "response to the article AL Pono
haze ", 1997} ... the star Venus
September 9, the 887 could not be observed not
because the sun was in the sky at a specified
Fomenko time, but because the sun was
too close to the planet to the last
could be seen.

{Nosovskij GV, Fomenko, "Once more on to
coverages stars planets described in the Al
mageste "Ptolemy", 1998} ... conditions apparently
bridge with the Earth this cover was bad
(See below). Nevertheless, on the north
latitudes Venus is likely to still be
was seen at sunset in a few
minutes.