The Phenomenon of J.R.R. Tolkien: Book and Life
Musings
-------=======
THE PHENOMENON OF J.R.R. TOLKIEN: BOOK AND LIFE
They came to the Club straight from a field game, lucky for them that it was +25 Celsius outside and the weather was sunny. “The Unicorns.” He was in light armor, with a sword on his back; she wore a tunic, with a dagger at her belt. People turned around, nodded their heads “knowingly,” and smiled. And the “Unicorns,” paying them no attention, walked over to our spot and started talking. What about—it doesn’t matter; what matters is that they were happy and having fun...
From the life of the Big Club.
Who hasn’t written about him: theologians, psychologists, literary scholars, philologists, politicians... But all this fuss didn’t bother him in the least; he probably wasn’t aware of what was taking shape in his typewriter. And most likely, the passions that flared up around his writings amused Tolkien at first, then left him puzzled. In any case, for twenty years after The Lord of the Rings came out, he kept quiet, merely smirking as he watched the commotion and puffed on his pipe, rocking in his chair on the veranda of his little house.
The most-read author of the second half of the twentieth century, beloved by critics and ordinary readers alike, “the old hobbit,” as some call him, and “the wise Gandalf,” as others acknowledge—J.R.R. Tolkien, the venerable Oxford don whose fairy tale became a life for many...
He was born in 1892 in the Orange Republic (South Africa). In 1894, his mother brought the children (a younger brother had arrived) to England. In 1895, his father died; from 1896 to 1899, the family lived in a country cottage in the little village of Sarehole, a mile from Birmingham. A completely new world opened up to four-year-old Tolkien: the rural provinces, what the English call the countryside, which did much to shape the future writer.
He read Alice in Wonderland at an early age and, like many others, loved this fairy tale for “children and grown-ups.” He loved reading stories about Indians and often ran around the neighborhood with a bow and arrows (a role-player by nature—that’s a diagnosis ;). At last, he found the reading that was truly his: Scandinavian legends, books by the English writer George MacDonald, later called by critics “the first swallows” of the now-popular fantasy genre, and Andrew Lang’s fairy tales, full of dragons, noble knights, and beautiful princesses...
In industrial Birmingham, little J.R.R. found an unexpected amusement: he was drawn to the inscriptions on the huge dump trucks hauling coal. They looked like English, but Tolkien had no idea how to pronounce that jumble of letters. That was how he discovered the ancient, but still living, language of the people of Wales—Welsh, in which he would later earn a reputation as a world-renowned expert.
At school, John met an energetic teacher named George Brewerton, who introduced the boy to yet another language: Old English. Then came the years of study at Oxford and his first serious literary passions (to the languages he had already learned he added new ones—Ancient Greek and even the “exotic” Finnish, in which Tolkien finally read the Kalevala).
At sixteen, John met a girl named Edith Bratt, a neighbor in the house where the brothers had moved with the help of their guardian after their mother’s death. Edith was beautiful—or perhaps she only seemed so to John, but what a…
The Phenomenon of J.R.R. Tolkien: Book and Life
Fragment 2/4
…a difference. The young couple were able to marry only in 1926. One can only envy them. Everything was like a fairy tale: they lived happily ever after, raised four children, and both died in ripe old age…
And that was that. J.R.R.’s youth was over, and with it, the hardships left his life. The remaining half-century passed with remarkable calm for a brilliant scholar of the Middle Ages, a respected professor, a homebody, slightly old-fashioned in his tastes and preferences, a loving husband and…
Just an ordinary life, nothing extraordinary at all—except for five books, which somehow surfaced in the midst of his dull biography and turned a respectable old man into an idol of a new, noisy and impetuous generation.
People understand his books in different ways; each sees his own revelation in them… J.R.R. himself once wrote a parable:
THE PARABLE OF THE TOWER
A man built a tower from stones taken from ancient ruins. And people began to admire it and argue about where the stones had come from and how it had been built. Then, in the heat of their arguments, they pulled it apart, stone by stone, to settle their doubts—besides, many of the old stones bore traces of wonderful carvings that could not otherwise be admired. The tower was gone. What a pity—for it had been tall and beautiful, and from its summit one could see the Sea…
On the very eve of 1930, a young professor of Anglo-Saxon literature at one of Oxford’s colleges began, almost as if in passing, to write a children’s fairy tale about a comical and touching little people—the hobbits. The book appeared in 1938, published by “Allen & Unwin,” and sold quite well, though it caused no sensation. Even so, the publisher advised the novice author to think about continuing it…
With the painstaking thoroughness of a true specialist, Tolkien began adding all kinds of scholarly appendices to the tale. He drew up family trees for his characters, invented an imaginary calendar for his fairy-tale land and learned it by heart, along with its chronology—from there, it was but a short step to creating a “historical background”! He created an alphabet… And so, stone by stone, from what had seemed an artless children’s fairy tale, an entire artistic world was built—in the literal sense, a whole cosmos. Middle Earth—Middle-earth; the name comes from the ancient Scandinavian Milgaard—the Middle Earth-World, as distinct from the Upper World, the heavenly one, and the Lower World, the underground one…
The gigantic book in three volumes—which contains a story spanning two full years, plus a detailed chronology covering the preceding six and a half thousand years and more than a hundred years thereafter (!); three and a half hundred characters; six dozen beautiful songs, poems and ballads; and who could count how many layers of plot and meaning?—was completed only in 1948, and did not see the light of day until 1955.
It is simply impossible to find a suitable all-embracing term for the English writer’s creation, because nothing like it had ever before existed in literature. Here, for example, are a few interpretations by American and English literary scholars, taken from a single collection of essays, Tolkien and the Critics, published in 1968:
A tale of a heroic odyssey, of a war campaign rich in adventure. An ethical chronicle of the world of Middle-earth. A story about an ordinary “cog,” raised by fate to the hidden levers that govern the universe. A moral parable about the corrupting nature of power—and a “historical” account of how it was toppled from its throne. A philosophical novel about the eternal…
The Phenomenon of J.R.R. Tolkien: Book and Life
Fragment 3/4
…battle, and the unity of Good and Evil that so many stubbornly refuse to see, and each person’s responsibility for a wrong once committed. There is simply no suitable general term for the work of the English writer, because nothing like it had existed in literature before. The scale is what confounds us above all: a grand mystery on a cosmic scale, hundreds of characters, and an extraordinary level of detail in the epic novel—a literally hour-by-hour chronology. An entire fictional world: open, changeable, bursting from the pages.
The philosophical foundation of this Not-a-Fairy-Tale is also unconventional.
The free choice of a thinking person—that is what the edifice of morality in Tolkien’s world is built upon. Not on lawlessness and anarchy (which would be strange for a Christian writer, as J.R.R. remained until his final days), but neither on blind adherence to dogma: on free choice, grounded in knowledge.
The characters—the hobbit Frodo and his companions—are also, in a way, symbols. Gandalf symbolizes a power to match the magic of the Rings: wisdom. And although his direct intervention in the course of events is kept to a minimum, it is doubtful that the little hobbit could have completed his mission without the wizard’s spiritual support.
The difference between a traditional fairy-tale hero (even one who starts out as Ivanushka the Fool) and Frodo Baggins is enormous. And it is not because of Frodo’s personal modesty: he does not fit the role of a stock hero for another reason, too—he is constantly torn, constantly tormented by the responsibility that has fallen upon him: will he manage? At times he suffers bouts of weakness, even despair; he can be indecisive and make mistakes. In short, he is a person, not a “hero.” This is not the folkloric Frodo the Fool, setting out to fight yet another dragon, but the “little man” of realistic fiction, suddenly finding himself at the center of cosmic clashes. Frodo becomes a hero, a shaper of destinies—not all at once, not easily, not by simply deciding to. For him, it is a drama.
And Sauron, lord of Mordor, fears not Frodo the fighter for justice, but Frodo the rival—as if he himself wanted to take the throne and rule wisely and justly. But the hobbit’s goal is different: to destroy the very temptation of Power. Little Frodo thinks and acts as though he has known since childhood: “All power corrupts,” along with many other truths. He thinks and acts like a person of the twentieth century—even though he is not a person at all, and the time in which the drama takes place is lost in a fairy-tale “long, long ago”…
Remember how the victory of Good over Evil ends in a traditional fairy tale? We know: with a crown, a princess, and half a kingdom thrown in. The author of The Lord of the Rings, who lived through nearly three-quarters of the twentieth century, thought otherwise. The temptation of Power—with a capital P—is a motif introduced by the departing century. And there is the ancient legend of Aragorn’s ancestor, one of the heroes, who did not destroy the Ring of Omnipotence, but yielded to its temptation—and was ultimately crushed by power…
Tolkien’s professional knowledge of medieval history suggested the image of a world knocked from its familiar orbit, where entire peoples migrate and some disappear without a trace. And, in essence, it does not matter that Frodo ultimately fulfills his mission and returns home. Because it is a strange and sad homecoming: along with the magic of the Rings, all magic—good and evil alike—leaves Middle-earth. Middle-earth itself changes, becomes ever more “legendary,” and Men arrive. This symbolic passing of the baton from Tolkien’s fairy-tale heroes to Men is no accident: Tolkien’s fairy tale, breaking genre boundaries once again, stepped into our real…
The Phenomenon of J.R.R. Tolkien: Book and Life
Fragment 4/4
I read The Hobbit when I was ten, and, honestly, I was lucky: back then nobody had heard of Tolkien, and the story was published in some collection. (Today that’s almost hard to believe. ;) And I forgot about it... Then, in 1991, The Lord of the... (“Rainbow edition”) appeared in our library, and I immediately remembered that childhood story. The new book became more than just a fairy tale—it became a revelation, hazy and still incomprehensible, but very interesting; a book to read in one sitting. I fell ill, but didn’t find any “kindred spirits” back then, and after I recovered, something bright and good remained in my soul... forever.
And some people were lucky (or unlucky, depending on how you look at it :) and found one another—those who became “Tolkien-crazed,” who embraced the Book and believed in it, those whose childhood attachment never faded, but stayed with them for life. Clubs and “orders” appeared, and in time communities of “roleplayers” took shape: those eternal children, actors, whose lives are unthinkable without the Game, who are happy and cheerful despite the hardships of our lives, because our life is also a Game—more real, but no less playable.
Then came computers and role-playing games, but a “real roleplayer” will never choose them over a friend from the club’s still-clumsy but “own” module (“he’ll learn, he’ll become a real Master”) or a live “field game,” where you can stretch your legs, have fun, and play out your character...
There’s no need to go looking for the origins of the History of Middle-earth—you might lose it. The world Tolkien created sprang from Scandinavian legends, but it is a complete whole, its own colorful world. It has a history, a population, rules for existing in it... Those who understood it, accepted it, belong to it. Associations spring up, and a fairy tale for adults becomes a reflection of their lives—our lives, so familiar. And unfamiliar.
Sequels and refutations appear... The Not-a-Fairy-Tale is reinterpreted. I recently even heard someone say that “Tolkien was a necromancer!” After all, there’s a word “Hogbi” in the Runes (doesn’t it sound like something? ;) and it means “a loathsome dwarf living in graves”
And it’s unclear whether the Not-a-Fairy-Tale became life, or, conversely, life became the Not-a-Fairy—
Tolkien’s last photograph was taken shortly
before his death, on August 9, 1973.
The old professor leans with one hand
on his cane, and with the other holds on
to the mighty trunk of a “black pine”
(one of the attractions of Oxford’s Botanic
Garden; those who knew the writer say it
was J.R.R.’s favorite tree). The trunk is
indeed mighty; under trees like these
wandering knights would sit and catch
their breath after battles with dragons, while
travelers told legends and tales of times
long past to chance companions.
And it seems that, as he touched the giant
tree, old Tolkien himself went off into the
Not-a-Fairy-Tale he had once invented. And
instead of the old-fashioned jacket and
knitted vest he’s wearing, there’s a rough
traveling cloak with a hood. And in his hands,
instead of an elegant little stick with a curved
handle, a heavy, gnarled staff. The kindly old
wizard, the tireless wanderer Gandalf, has
stopped in the shade of the mighty crown to
rest. He has come a long way, and the road
ahead is still long...
Gandalf is in no hurry. Good wizards
live a long time.
I Wasn’t There. And I Didn’t See Any Hobbits! ;)
Share your thoughts about the article