Kaleidoscope — J. R. R. Tolkien on Women, Love, and Marriage

Modern #18

Kaleidoscope

╔═────────────────────────────═╗
                │      J. R. R. Tolkien       │
                │ on women, love, and marriage │
                ╚═────────────────────────────═╝

Tolkien is, first and foremost, the creator of Arda to us. But what was he like in real life: among friends, at university, at home? Above all, Tolkien was a man of intellectual labor (in the most literal sense!)—the work of the mind occupied an enormous place in his life. So we can begin to get to know him by asking, “What did he think about...?” Well, what did Tolkien think about such a serious issue as relations between the sexes?

Tolkien’s family life might seem to have been happy. At eighteen, he fell in love with Edith Bratt, and six years later, having overcome every obstacle, he married her. They had four children, good and loving, and spiritually close to their father. They lived together for no more and no less than 55 years, and on the gravestone beside their names are written: LÚTHIEN and BEREN. An idyll? Tolkien himself didn’t think so. The more romantic and exalted his youthful love for his own Lúthien had been, the harder it proved to steer the family ship through the everyday routine of marriage, weathering storms of passion and the calms of domestic life. True to his habit of getting to the heart of things, Tolkien thought a great deal about the psychological problems of relations between the sexes, mercilessly casting aside the pretty veils of cultural and literary tradition. The starting point for these reflections was his strict, uncompromising Catholicism (“our pitiless, stern religion,” as he himself put it). Even today, the boldness of his conclusions is surprising (though that doesn’t stop them from seeming somewhat old-fashioned—Tolkien was, after all, quite conservative). We can learn something of the results of this work of mind and heart from a letter Tolkien wrote to his son Michael in early March 1941. The war was raging. Michael, then 21, was serving in the Air Force, and his unit was based in South Africa. Apparently, Michael had shared some of his worries and problems with his father. Here are excerpts from Tolkien’s reply.

…A man’s attitude toward women may be limited to the purely physical side (in reality, that never happens, but a man can force himself to ignore everything else, doing great harm to his own soul—and not only his own—and to his body as well); it may be “friendly,” or he may “love” (all the powers of soul and body merge into one complex feeling, whose brightness and power owe much to the sexual instinct, to sex). Our world is a fallen world, and one of the main symptoms of the Fall is the distortion of the sexual instinct. The social forms of human life change, but each one sets its own traps for people. Let’s not talk about what is called “filth”—you want nothing to do with that. You have no calling to live as a recluse. So, “friendship”? In our fallen world, “friendship,” which ought to be possible between any two people, is practically impossible between a man and a woman. The devil’s ingenuity is boundless, and sex is his favorite field of activity. He knows how to catch his victim in the most innocent and romantic feelings, to say nothing of the more crude ones. There have been many attempts at this kind of “friendship,” and almost always one of the two has failed the test. At a later age, when sexual feeling grows dull, such relationships are possible. They are possible among saints. But they are very rare between ordinary young people. Almost certainly one of the partners, forgetting their good intentions, will fall in love with the other. In truth, a young man, whatever he may say, is not looking for “friendship” at all. He is looking for love, but innocent love that demands no responsibility. But then, if he is a Christian and understands what sin is, he has to think about what to do next.

In our Western culture, the romantic chivalric tradition idealizing “love” is still strong. There is a good side to this, because it teaches people to seek more in love than the pleasures of the flesh; it teaches them to value, if not purity, then at least fidelity, self-sacrifice, “service,” courtesy, honor, and courage. But this tradition began as an artificial courtly game, and it values love for its own sake, regardless of marriage (more precisely, in defiance of it). The center of this love is not God, but imaginary deities: Love and the Lady. The impulse to see the Lady as a guiding star or a deity has survived to this day. So has the old cliché: thanks to “his deity” (= the woman he loves), a man becomes ennobled. This is, of course, a lie; at best, a delusion. A woman is just as fallen a creature as a man, and her soul is beset by dangers too. Chivalric adoration (combined with Christianity) might be considered the ideal of love between a man and a woman, but it seems to me there are dangers here. After all, this ideal is purely “theoretical” and does not quite correspond to the truth. Adoration of the Lady keeps a young man from seeing a woman for what she really is: a fellow survivor of a shipwreck, not a guiding star; and from taking account of her desires, needs, and temptations (one consequence: once his illusions are gone, a man becomes cynical). “True love” is understood as some fire that has descended from who knows where, as a state of constant exaltation, independent of such prosaic circumstances as age,

the birth of children, and everyday life. The meaning of “true love” is exaggerated beyond all measure, as if it had nothing to do with will or life plans (one consequence: young people seek a love that, without any effort on their part, will give them warmth and comfort in this cold world—and even divorce cannot cure them of this romantic notion).

    This applies to women to a lesser extent, though they too use the language of romantic love—our speech is steeped in it through and through. The sexual instinct makes a woman (except for the spoiled and selfish ones) accommodating and understanding—or at least makes her try to be, or at least seem to be. If she likes a young man, she readily takes an interest in what interests him, from ties to religion. This is not pretense: it is the instinct of a helper and a slave at work, stirred by the play of young blood and desire.

    Often she becomes remarkably perceptive, and starts taking an interest even in things she was previously completely indifferent to. For such is woman’s nature: to receive from a man, to be impregnated by him (and not only in the physical sense). Every teacher knows this: a bright female student grasps his ideas on the fly and understands his arguments, but let her lose interest in his person—and, as a rule, she immediately loses both interest and the ability to work. The same is the natural course of a woman in love. Before she has even understood what is happening (while the romantic young man, if he pays her any attention at all, is still only sighing), she may “fall in love.” For a normal, unspoiled woman, this means (even if she herself is unaware of it) that she wants to become the mother of his children. From there, events may take several courses, including a very sad one, if the young man needed only a temporary “guiding star” (until a brighter one appeared), while in the meantime he was flattered by her attention, seasoned with a little sexual excitement of his own. No, of course it is all quite innocent; we are not talking about a “seducer” at all.

    In life (and in literature), you may encounter flighty and even “fatal” women. I mean women who lack the sense to take even love seriously; women who enjoy a duel with a man (not to be confused with ordinary coquetry!); women who like causing pain. But these are deviations from the norm...

    Literature was created mostly by men (if we leave aside the modern novel), and the image of the “beautiful and faithless” woman occurs in it very often. This is, frankly, slander. Women are human too, of course, and therefore capable of treachery. But by nature they are far less treacherous than men. Unless a man asks a woman to “wait” for him too long, while her youth (so essential for a future mother) quickly slips away. One should not make a woman wait... Our times have changed upbringing and lifestyle, but our natural endowments have not changed. A man has work, a career, male friends. He will keep all of these (provided he has enough character), even if he suffers a “failure” in love. A young woman, even if she is, as people say nowadays, “economically independent” (meaning that she works away from home, not for her husband and family, but somewhere else, for a male entrepreneur), usually starts thinking about wedding bells and her own...

home. And if she has fallen seriously in love, a shipwreck in love may prove a catastrophe for her. Women, however, are generally much less romantic, more practical. They may sound more sentimental, like to say “darling” and all that. Don’t let that fool you. They don’t need a guiding star. Of course, a woman may imagine an unremarkable young man to be a hero, but she doesn’t need to do that in order to fall in love. The one serious delusion women have is the belief that a man can be reformed. That is why a woman may marry an unworthy man with her eyes wide open... In matters of love, young women are far more clear-headed than men; imagination plays an incomparably smaller part for them. They are indifferent to “indecent” talk and jokes, but not because they are supposedly “purer” than men: it simply doesn’t amuse them. Of course, they join in such conversations and pretend to find them interesting because it’s fashionable, but deep down they don’t understand what’s supposed to be funny.

Women are by no means “purer,” though of course they have to be more careful: sex is more dangerous for them, both physically and in terms of their social standing. But a woman is monogamous by nature. A man is not. There’s no point pretending otherwise. Men are not monogamous; that is their physical nature. In the course of his life, a man is capable of fathering hundreds of children—and getting a great deal of pleasure out of it. We live in a fallen world, and our souls and bodies are not in harmony.

The fundamental characteristic of the fallen world is that you cannot attain perfection through pleasure alone—or, as people say nowadays, “through self-fulfillment” (which usually means indulging yourself while remaining utterly indifferent to other people’s “fulfillment”). Only through self-denial and suffering! That is precisely what fidelity in a Christian marriage demands: great humility of spirit and flesh. For a Christian, there is no other way. Marriage purifies his sexual desires and directs them into the right channel. Marriage can help him in the struggle. But the struggle remains. Marriage does not solve the problem. It helps, while at the same time creating new difficulties. There is no man—no matter how much he loved his wife before the wedding and for a while afterward—who would remain faithful to her not only in body but in thought, without a conscious effort of will, without self-restraint. Even among those brought up within the (Catholic) Church, few were warned about this in advance. Those outside the Church have usually never even heard of it. When the enchantment fades (or at least weakens), a man begins to think he made a mistake and has not yet met his true partner. His “true partner” very often turns out to be the next sexually attractive woman he meets, who might have made him a good wife if... So, divorce, to make that “if” come true? And, as a rule, he is right: he really did make a mistake. Only a very intelligent person is capable, at the end of his life, of judging whom he really should have married! Almost every marriage, even a successful one, is a mistake in the sense that almost certainly (in a more perfect world, or even in this imperfect one, with a little care) each partner could have found someone more suitable. But your “true partner” is the one you are already married to. In reality, you had very little say in the choice; for the most part, it was made for you...

chose life and circumstances (although, if God exists, these are merely instruments of His will). It is well known that successful marriages are more common where parents or family influence the “choice” made by young people: ordinary, non-romantic ethics demand responsibility and marital fidelity. Yet even in countries where the romantic tradition has gained such power that people believe no one should influence the choices young people make, only the rarest stroke of luck can bring together a man and a woman truly made for each other, as it were, and capable of a great, beautiful love. The dream of such love still beckons us, grips our hearts. Countless poems and novels have been written about it—perhaps more than there have been examples of such love in real life. (And yet the greatest of these poems and novels tell not of lovers’ happy life together, but of their tragic separation—as though, in our fallen world, even in love, what is truly great and beautiful can be attained only by way of “failure” and suffering.) It seems to me that such a great, irresistible love, often love at first sight, can give us an idea of what marriage ought to have been in a world unfallen. But in our fallen world, only prudence, wisdom (rarely found in youth, and too late in old age), a pure heart, and steadfastness of will can help us...

This article is taken from Palantir, the journal of the Tolkien Society of St. Petersburg.
Translated by T.L. Figlin

                        °∙· The End ·∙°
 ·                                                            ·
·∙· ▐▐▌▌▐▐▌▌▐▐▌▌▐▐▌▌▐▐▌▌▐▐▌▌▐▐▌▌▐▐▌▌▐▐▌▌▐▐▌▌▐▐▌▌▐▐▌▌▐▐▌▌ ·∙·
 ·                                                            ·

Share your thoughts about the article