Criticism — Andrzej Sapkowski on Tolkien and the Arthurian archetype

Fenzin #03

Criticism: A. Sapkowski on Fantasy. Continued

-------======= Criticism =======-------

Andrzej Sapkowski

“Varenik, or There Is No Gold in the Grey Mountains”
(c) “Nowa Fantastyka”, 1997
(c) translated by Evgeny Weisbrot, “ЕСЛИ”, 1997

<continued; beginning in the previous issue>

THE SUMMONED—THE PURSUED

It was precisely this lyrical melancholy, this sadness for time slipping away and an era coming to an end, seasoned with optimism and hope, that Tolkien so artistically put to use in The Lord of the Rings. Tears welled up in my eyes when the Ship carried Frodo away from the Havens, and when Sam told Rosie he had just returned. Yes, yes. Master Tolkien rode roughshod over the Arthurian archetype like a Don Cossack across the steppe. Well, he was the First and the Great. Anyone who later set off on the same trail earned the label of an epigone. And how could they not? It was the very same archetype!

In Master Tolkien’s favor, it must be said that he used this archetype so brilliantly, and invested so much effort in turning it into a tale his contemporaries could absorb, that he created an archetype of his own: the Tolkien archetype.

Let’s repeat the experiment. Let’s turn once more to a fantasy book taken from our shelf and see what it’s about.

Well, then: our hero lives a more or less rural life and is doing quite nicely. Suddenly, a mysterious figure appears, usually a wizard, and tells the protagonist that he must set off at once, without delay, on a Great Quest, because the fate of the world depends on him. For Evil is preparing to attack Good. And the only thing that can be set against Evil is a Magic Thing. The Magic Thing, meanwhile, is hidden Somewhere Over There, Who the Fuck Knows Where: most likely in the Grey Mountains, where, as everyone knows, there is no gold.

The summoned “hero” opens his eyes wide, since in even his wildest dreams he never imagined—not even hoped—that the fate of the world might depend on him. He has some doubts about what the wizard says, but then the Black Emissaries of Evil inevitably and unexpectedly attack him, and he has to run from them. He runs to a Nice Place, where he finds a moment’s peace and learns about the Legend and the Destiny. What can you do? There’s no way out. The protagonist is forced to undertake the Great Quest, using the map the author thoughtfully placed at the beginning of the book. The map is positively crawling with Mountains, Thickets, Swamps and Deserts, all generously scattered about and bearing Terrifying Names. It doesn’t matter that the Enemy’s Headquarters, which he has to reach, is on the northern or eastern edge of the map. You can be sure the hero will zigzag his way there, since he has to visit every Terrifying Place. In fantasy, walking straight roads is strictly contraindicated, even forbidden.

Naturally, the hero can’t travel alone, so they quickly assemble a Band for him—a company of colorful and spirited characters. Needless to say, everything proceeds in zigzags, and adventures in Terrifying Places, where the blood freezes in your veins, alternate with bucolic respites in Friendly Valleys. Evil will be defeated, at least until the author gets the urge to write a sequel—in which case Evil will “rise again” and the whole thing will have to start over.

Thus, the whole mighty wave of post-Tolkien fantasy is a genre that offers little new: formulaic, low-grade, nonsensical, and undeserving of serious discussion. Such is

Critics’ opinions—and what else is there to take into account, if not their opinions?

Incidentally, besides the derivative plots, there are two more things to consider: fantasy authors’ unhealthy craving for constructing multi-volume sagas and... book covers.

FACE TO FACE WITH THE FANATICS

A book cover is its calling card. If we see a title daubed in letters dripping with blood, and just below it a snarling face with bulging eyes, we can say at once that this is a low-grade “horror story”—in other words, a load of shit. If, on the other hand, the cover features a half-naked babe in the hero’s arms, with the hero holding a scimitar, while a dragon with the appearance of a scrawny axolotl looks down on the whole scene from above, then we are dealing with bargain-basement, pathetic fantasy.

Why does this happen? Why, one might ask, does the publisher slap a label on his own product with his own hand, loudly proclaiming that it’s cheap trash? The answer is simple. The publisher is aiming at the so-called FANATIC, and the so-called FANATIC wants to see a picture by Boris Vallejo on the cover. The FANATIC wants to gaze at naked buttocks and breasts just about bursting out of starched bras. The FANATIC is not looking for meaning in fantasy—the very meaning that ought to be shouting at the top of its lungs that nobody charges into battle wearing filigree armor, because in such armor you can’t even push your way through the nettle thickets growing thickly over the ravines and gullies of the Dark Forests and the slopes of the Grey Mountains, where, as everyone knows, there is no gold.

It gives the impression that fantasy as a genre has been so frightened of critics that, in its development, it has begun to use a peculiar kind of mimicry—as though it had renounced all claims and completely given up the fight for a place on Olympus. Fantasy does not demand recognition; herds of FANATICS are enough for it—people who buy everything that appears on the shelves. The best example of this is the well-known fantasy cycles and series, with their disturbingly large numbers of sequels.

The record in this respect probably belongs to a certain Alan Burt Akers, whose “Scorpio” cycle runs to more than forty volumes. Old bore Piers Anthony is no slouch either: he scribbled exactly thirty books in his “Xanth” series, and along the way churned out another seven sequels to the “Apprentice Adept” cycle, four “Tarot” books, and a mass of other books and cycles. John Norman, whom we’ll get to later, has about eleven volumes of the “Gor” cycle to his name. The modest authors who settled for sagas of five, four, or even just three volumes are impossible to list, for their name is Legion.

Criticism: A. Sapkowski on Fantasy. Continued

THIRST FOR MONEY?

It is curious that most authors who churn out dreadful sagas are talented, skillful, and interesting writers. So why do good writers crank out volume after volume, stretching their series, instead of using their ideas to write something entirely new? I think I know the answer. Authors fall in love with their heroes; they find it hard to part with them. Realizing there’s not another drop to squeeze from their protagonists, they start cobbling together more volumes about their descendants.

Authors fall in love with their worlds and maps. If there are Grey Mountains on such a map, and five volumes weren’t enough for the protagonist to discover that there’s no gold there, then a sixth volume gets written. And in the next one, the seventh, a neighboring section of the map will appear, and we’ll find out what lies north of the Grey Mountains—and that will undoubtedly be the Plateau of Grey Shit.

And finally, authors are, essentially, lazy, and simply don’t want to think. Authors are limited idiots, and no matter how hard they try, they can’t strike anything original out of themselves with a flint, so they’re forced to keep flapping the same worn-out formula in the wind. Besides, authors are calculating beasts—they’re interested only in the money they get for each volume.

And all of this—note well!—was written by someone who churns out “Witchers”!

So far, the person who churns out “Witchers” seems to acknowledge the truth of the anti-fantasy critics, who insist—I repeat, following Marek Oramus—that the genre is wretched. I agree: taken as a whole, the genre has become terribly depleted. However, I cannot agree with those who claim that this wretchedness is a consequence of the action taking place in made-up worlds, and the heroes being armed with swords. I would claim nothing more than that science fiction, cyberpunk, and so on are no less wretched as a whole. No one will convince me that a world destroyed by war or cataclysm, where everyone fights everyone else, and all together fight the mutants, is better than a quasi-feudal world where everyone fights everyone else, and all together hunt goblins. No matter how hard I try, I can’t see why a flight to Tau Ceti is better or more worthy than an expedition to the Grey Mountains, where, as we know, there’s no gold. A mutinous onboard computer is no better to me than a treacherous sorcerer, and a laser blaster is no more worthy in my eyes than a sword, halberd, or iron-shod flail. And the superiority of pilot Pirx or Ender over Conan, which I readily acknowledge, certainly doesn’t come from the fact that the first two wear spacesuits while the third wears a loincloth.

LE GUIN AGAINST TOLKIEN

However, in modern fantasy one can observe a certain tendency—a clear desire to break free from the Arthurian-Tolkienian mold. These attempts are made almost exclusively by women writers. In the fantasy of recent years, there has been a decisive ascendancy of ladies with pens.

The revolution began with Ursula Le Guin, who created only one classic fantasy—yet one so remarkable that it put her on a pedestal beside the master Tolkien. I am speaking of the Earthsea books. With dangerous ease, Mrs. Ursula broke free of Tolkien’s rut and rejected the Arthurian archetype in favor of symbolism and allegory. But what kind?

The Earthsea Archipelago itself is a profound allegory: islands scattered across the sea, like lonely, isolated people. The people of Earthsea are lonely, too, because they have lost Something. They lack the lost Rune of the Kings, from the broken Ring of Erreth-Akbe, without which they cannot attain complete happiness and peace.

In the first volume, we are presented with the classic problem of Good and Evil. There is also the hero’s expedition. But Ged’s journey is unlike the usual treks into the Grey Mountains—it is an allegory, an eternal farewell and parting, eternal loneliness. Ged strives for perfection by battling himself; he triumphs by uniting with the element of Evil, thereby acknowledging the duality of human nature. He attains perfection while acknowledging, however, that absolute perfection is unattainable. We even doubt whether Ged has truly attained perfection—and rightly so.

The Tombs of Atuan takes us further into the byways of the psyche. There is the Atuan labyrinth, lifted straight from archetype—from the Cretan labyrinth of Minos. Like the Cretan labyrinth, the Atuan labyrinth conceals its Minotaur. Not a classical monster that roars, drools, paws the earth and tears off ears, all the while laughing evilly. The Minotaur of the Atuan labyrinth is concentrated evil in its purest form. Evil that destroys the psyche, especially an incomplete, imperfect psyche, unprepared for such encounters.

Into this labyrinth strides Ged, the hero, Theseus. And, like Theseus, Ged is doomed to have his Ariadne. His Ariadne is Tenar. Ged, the mighty mage, suddenly turns into a frightened child—in the labyrinth’s treasury, in the darkness steeped in the breath of Evil, he is saved by the touch of Tenar’s hand. Ged follows his anima—for he must. Because he has, after all, found the lost Rune of Erreth-Akbe. A symbol. The Grail. A woman.

And the archetype works once again: just like Theseus, Ged abandons Ariadne. Now Tenar grows into a mighty symbol, a very modern and very feminist allegory. An allegory of femininity.

After an eighteen-year break, Mrs. Ursula writes Tehanu, a continuation of the series, a continuation of her allegory of femininity—this time triumphant.

In Tehanu, as one might expect, the broken and destroyed Ged crawls on his knees to his anima, and now she knows how to keep him, what role to assign him, so that she can become everything to him, the greatest purpose and meaning of his life; so that this former Archmage will stay with her until the end of his days, squealing with delight like a piglet while he’s at it. And a joyless future awaits the conceited wizards of the island of Roke: a job at a company under a woman director. Oh, ho-ho-ho!

SONS OF AMAZONS — DAUGHTERS OF GIANTS

“Tehanu” came late. During those eighteen years, an avalanche of feminist fantasy swept through the shelves of bookstores. With one common theme: a woman in a man’s world. A woman in the world of Conans, just as a woman in the world of Fords, Rockefellers, and Lecoqs. No worse than them, but better. It takes hard work and a fierce struggle, but better all the same. Women—the heroines of Marion Zimmer Bradley, C.J. Cherryh, Tanith Lee, Barbara Hambly, Patricia McKillip, Julian May, Diana Paxson, Mercedes Lackey, Jane Yolen, Paula Volsky, Sheri S. Tepper, Jennifer Roberson, Susan Dexter, Patricia Kennealy, Freda Warrington, Jane Morris, Margaret Weis, Phyllis Eisenstein, Judith Tarr, and others.

“Ladies’” fantasy is a reflection of militant feminism at the turn of the sixties and seventies: women fighting the “male chauvinist pigs” who boss them around even in Dreamland.

John Norman takes the prize for bossing women around. His “Gor” series positively oozes with the obvious hang-ups and problems that the author ought to rush to a sexologist about as soon as possible, before they reach the manic stage. The heroes in John Norman’s books do nothing but rape. And before a woman in John Norman’s books can be raped, she absolutely has to be tied up, chained, whipped, and branded with a hot iron.

In feminist fantasy stories, women break out of the Conan-and-Gor mold. They can take a swing at a lout with a sword or hit him with a spell themselves, and even if someone does rape her—woe betide him! By no later than the fifth volume of the saga, he’ll pay dearly for it. Some female authors have gone a little too far with this. The heroines of Mercedes Lackey’s “Oathbound” series, the warrior Tarma and the sorceress Kethry, are raped over and over, then shake it off and take revenge.

In her “Last Herald-Mage” trilogy, the hero is a certain Vanyel, a man. I bought it because I wanted to find out what the authoress thinks of men. It turned out: quite a lot. Vanyel has some rather untypical erotic tastes for a man, and the authoress bends over backwards to convince the reader that this is precisely what tigers love above all else. I gave up on buying the next two volumes, scared by the prospect of what awaits the hero in them. In the equally typical “Lythande” series, by Marion Zimmer Bradley, the heroine is a sorceress disguised in men’s clothing. The sorceress graduated from a magic university disguised as a man. A transparent allegory of a woman’s self-sacrifice in trying to build a career at the firm “Rank

Well, since we’ve started talking about Zimmer Bradley, she is the inspiration behind the well-known “Sward & Sorseress” series—that is, pay attention!—“By the Sword and Female Magic” (my translation, and a very free one at that). The short-story collections that make up the series have already reached number ten and are doing quite well. When it comes to fantasy, these collections are pretty much the only good and proper place for newcomers and young writers to get a start. Or rather, women writers, given the leitmotif. Though they do sometimes let male authors in, too, but… see above. They must bow their heads and bend their knees; their… masculine pride must be weakened and laid low.

So I can see the future of the genre as clearly as the palm of my hand.

To be continued in the next issue

Share your thoughts about the article