History with history
Smirnov Vladimir
(pamphlet)
“I am a historian,” the scientist confirmed and added neither to the village nor to
to the city: - There will be an interesting story at the Patriarch's this evening!
M. Bulgakov
"The Master and Margarita"
At the end of August 2002, before the new school year, a whole
a series of meetings at different levels, various meetings, commissions. C
with or without the participation of the president, public organizations and
parliamentary representatives, academics and members
office. The main topic is “school reform”. In the end, truly
- the mountain gave birth to a mouse. A mountain of meetings, participants, a mountain of degrees,
positions and titles (up to “nowhere further”, further
"guarantor"). Twelve-year-old - this main “otherness” of ours
to the “civilized world” - it was decided due to the cool attitude
teachers, and public opinion in general, should not be allowed to move,
and put it aside. So, “for the future.” And the second ide-fixe, the idea of "one
state exam", greeted by universities, following a quiet general
sabotage, a lot of specific counterarguments, also moved away. "On
"experimental stage".
So was it necessary to stir up another reform mess? And for what?
then we need as much as “400 billion in 10 years”? Calm down.
Leave me alone. Relax! Take a break from your "reforms" - in
most are headless, senseless,destructive. After
which already had to be returned “as it was.” Examples? On
village sowing of our lands by an overseas “vegetable farmer” -
stopped, the process went back to collective farms. B
army, poor (our main “object of reform”), after the merger
military branches - again division; The Airborne Forces were almost cut, but they decided
strengthen the rocket men. Another example, well-known, or rather, “imposed on
teeth." In the “regions”, among those divided in the early 90s
"subjects of the federation", the reverse process of "enlargement" began and
"mergers". So was it necessary to initiate “reforms”??? (With new
"winds" from the Ministry of Education and from the field of medicine, isn't it?
I feel like we've already seen this! Just recently!! Although this
replica in a text from three years ago. But the meaninglessness and
futility of “reforms”, downright criminal nature
reforms are becoming more and more visible!)
After the past meetings, which, as we see, turned out to be a mouse
fiddling around, I still want to stop at one of them, from 2002.
Prime Minister Kasyanov looked into textbooks... In history textbooks... And
told us. The President "advised". "Indicated." The form, they say,
there is, but the content... Let's add, Vladimych, first about the quantity
- mad. Supply goes out of its way to demand. But not
goes into the quality of the quantity of proposals, remaining frantic.
And whoever doesn’t struggle! OK,The bird "Bustard" is local. But
here you have various others and “ours” and “yours”, various random ones
“scribblers”, and even overseas authors with textbooks of the same “History”.
Supported by Soros and the like. Oh those school books
stories! Permanent scandal!
The President spoke about the indignation of veterans with a history textbook
Dolutsky. Another time, M. Kasyanov quoted the
“with surprise” in history textbooks terms: “working class”,
"labor intelligentsia" and some others. Here on these
terms, as well as the minister’s surprise, let’s stop.
We can agree that the words from criminal law
jargon (“legal chaos”) has no place in school. But apparently not
The authors did it! They can be understood. Criminal jargon
committing linguistic aggression, at first he settled quietly, in
in quotation marks, on newspaper pages. Then the writing brethren (pack?) are all
more often I began to forget to “protect myself”, to guard against crime
in quotation marks. (And in the pronunciation of TV announcers, the quotation marks are not visible.
It was necessary either not to pronounce it at all, or to make a reservation: “so
called". And it would be better not to have it in your dictionary. But here
learned... "Life will teach you, life will force you." Yes,
will force. "Living with wolves is like a wolf... fuck!")
But let us turn to other terms that “surprised” the minister. What do we want
afraid of the term "titular nation"? Premier -objects... Yes,
this fits well with the policy of the last ten years on
liquidation of the Russian people! Eliminate the nation by eliminating the column
in the passport... Perhaps even the Nazis would not have thought of this!!
It’s good that at least other nations are raising their voices. That rare case now,
when we support Shaimiev and Shaimievites. But Zhirinovsky,
but Volkovich was WRONG again when at one of the meetings
stated on this score: there should not be a column about
nationality. So that, supposedly, no one has any
complexes. Well, well! It's your own nationality that can
become a complex! So much so that there will be a desire to hide it? This
what nationality? It seems to be the opposite: everyone is proud of their
nationality, whatever it may be. But no, it turns out, not all.
(Actually, Zhirinovsky has already said so much! And he said so much!
When will the voter see the light and stop voting for him?
"party"?) But, however, we digress. On today's schedule -
history. And the “historian” Mikhail Kasyanov. "Ah! Are you a historian? - s
Berlioz asked with great relief and respect."
So, as a “historian” I do not respect and do not recognize Kasyanov.
He didn't like the term "working class"...
I immediately remembered the semi-fantastic novel by V. Teitelboim
"Internal War", about the fascist coup in Chile in 1973.
There Pinochet is preparing a message about the coup,and American
the adviser (Dr. Frankenstein!) asks what he will write
about the working class? Pinochet: "I will not allow you to use
communist terms. I will eliminate this class." Doctor
was surprised and asked how? And I, he says, don’t
I'll mention it. And didn't mention it!!
Yes, yes! Following the Russians - in passports - they are trying to eliminate
all over the world the working class, and work, work. "Not mentioning." A
mentioning “working people”, or at most “working people”. Instead of
"labor exchange" (which we had until 1930), or, let's say,
"employment service" (which existed by the end of the 80s) - "service
employment." ("...Wine weaving"! ...Weaving. Vine-... Word-...)
There, in the novel, "Eneral" found the words - "groups of workers." But
recently he himself found justice, at least partially. When
stuck under investigation in Europe and feigned infirmity,
dying. So Kasyanov, following Pinochet (disciple!), wants
liquidate the working class. So what, eliminate all classes?
Destroying the class hatred of the current Marxist government
approach? No, not all. An illiterate stamp often used by newspapermen -
"middle class" - Kasyanov, of course, will approve. "Average" almost
It pleases the ear because it is average. So, they say, he doesn’t have much anymore
it is necessary, he supposedly has a lot. Sing us guys a song, what,
they say, “there” the middle class is the majority.Following
sexual minority! No!! It's better to be uncivilized
The East, with their harems, than the "civilized" West, with its
minorities-majorities, with its extreme confusion in all
spheres and injustice covered by “freedom”. Together with
Let us say to Zarathustra: I am not interested in what you are free from, but
- for what?? For nothing! The modern Western has no goals
society. And it can predict its future no more than
year As we do now: for no more than two presidential
term. What were they fighting for?
"Middle class" - this, at first glance, smooth term -
is slippery, false, deceitful. Illiterate. However, those
those who studied social studies and history poorly could like him.
And in vain! It is the working class that creates MATERIAL VALUES,
it is he who creates surplus value, and due to it, thus
Thus, it is he, the worker, who feeds his “employers.”
It is he, the “employer”. ("Employer"? One of seven,
who "with a spoon"!) And although the number of workers is decreasing
(automation, mechanization), but the worker was, is and, of course,
there will be! Should I rename it? Or call another group “average”,
another series of non-working people who actually constitute today
majority - different sellers, economic and political
speculators? It's a matter of taste. More precisely, a matter of principle. Principlesame in
that he, a worker, a creator, a physical laborer, is
"center of mass" of society, and you, the intelligentsia, are still
appendage, layer. (Ed.: However, the worker only represents
The MEANS, the intelligentsia determines the GOAL. A society of one
workers are generally unviable, let alone survivable in
cataclysms.) Or Kasyanov doesn’t like the “labor
intelligentsia” because he doesn’t get here? How does it not fall into
the notorious "creative intelligentsia". He is one of the
"bureaucratic intelligentsia". Or "speculative" - too
sells “product”: new ideas, in new, “ordered” textbooks.
With the term "creative intelligentsia" he still, apparently,
Do you agree? Well, the “labor intelligentsia” also exists -
Engineering and technical personnel at enterprises. Not everyone trades these days.
Besides our minister (with his surprise), there is another reason
talk about history books.
In those same last days of August, “developing” a suddenly flared
the prime minister's interest in textbooks, the helpful central press, RTR
and ORT, set out their content in terms of “modern history”.
It was mentioned several times that “newest” ends with
Primakov, and another quoted textbook talks about the “new
Prime Minister Kiriyenko and the tasks of his cabinet by the fall of 1998..."
Ironically, therefore, but also seriously regretting
unmentioned“the very, very newest”... What can I say? Much is possible
and it needs to be said. Putin, Kasyanov, Berezovsky, Gryzlov - all this
not yet “history” (“on the Patriarch’s”!! That’s when Annushka will shed
oil!..).
Kasyanov and Putin are not “history” yet. This is still "CURRENT"
EVENTS" reflected by the CURRENT PRESS. The desire is clear - to "get
into history" (on the rails?!). There are quite a few magazines ready
sympathize. And yet. Read the newspapers, kids. So that, here
namely, do not rewrite textbooks, do not rewrite facts, their
interpretation.
To become “history,” events and personalities must “pass away into history.”
time". Having received an assessment from him, time. Assessment,
expressed as a majority, “public opinion” (Ed.:
highlight such a puppet as “public opinion” as
I don’t recommend the characteristics of the story!), and the fact of the condition and
sustainable development. Otherwise, post-Yeltsin-post-Gorbachev
"reform", not only rewrites the assessment of the Great October Revolution, but
and even an assessment of the Great Patriotic War. The last one - many times: and
number of victims in vain and economic decline of more than
then, and many others, in particular, the lack of prospects. How
Yuri Polyakov writes: “I’ll say something terrible - we lost the 2nd World War!”
Why not? It's no longer scary. We see everything ourselves and know everything ourselves.
“Worse than during the war” - newspapers repeat these words of people
older generation.You can trust them, they made history, not
"passed" it. (Yes, even if only using Kasyanov’s textbooks!)
Let's summarize. As is customary at the end of the lesson (history, let us remind you).
Again we are convinced by the example of M.K. and other ministers-
capitalists: “History teaches that its lessons are ignored
studying." ("But these rascals don't want to know anything, don't want anything
study!") No, events do not follow the famous saying:
tragedy is a farce. Often it's the other way around. In the recent "93rd" execution
parliament was a tragedy on an international scale. AND EARLIER, in
"91", the events around the SAME building turned out to be a farce. First -
farce, then tragedy. Oh, this “terrible” State Emergency Committee! But ours
the shoot is ripe, our Boris. "Look at the FORM he's in" -
drunk again!! By the end of his reign he became downright HATED
to the population. They talked about his rating being 2%. Wrong! Minus 2.
Minus 80. Minus 95! Is there no such thing as a negative rating? We have -
it happens. For him, it happens! Was!!
But to this type, simply hated by everyone - and suddenly the Order "For
services to the fatherland"! And when? In 2001, when everyone and everything
has it become clear?!! No, our new “guarantor” is also sick. He definitely
will go down in history. This will be both the result and the assessment now
his actions. Not apostolic acts. Not godly, on the contrary, -
ungodly. "Successor"... What? Crimes? And crimes
continue! Criminal"reforms-perestroika".
He is trying to lean towards religion. You can lean against it, lean on it
- no!! You cannot build your life on lies, on religion. Traditional,
like, religion?! For you, an atheist! Is it the same for me?
Tell me the legend about the Jewish savior. About the Immaculate Conception
and the resurrection of the Jews. "Blessed is he who believes." Who is sinful?
he is blundering around and is about to deceive the big and small again!!
The state needs an idea. “A holy place is never empty”? It happens
as we see. The place of ideology is still empty. Lean here,
however, they intended to. Towards religion. To what doesn't exist. Like,
there is and, it seems, there is not. And it’s more likely not to be than to be. "Savior".
Let's save ourselves! Get up from your knees in your "temple", people!
"Grapevine, it's not your fault!"
But, let's say, one cannot help but believe in the virgin birth - we all
conceived precisely immaculately, including ministers, including Kasyanov, and
including the President of the Russian Federation. who sits his
due date, and sometimes, on September 1 or on a major date,
pays attention to history.
Then, in 2002, something caused Kasyanov’s indignation.
Indeed, one can be outraged by these textbook social
political protests that will never “cross the line”
civil war. You can be indignant. Because all the signs
wars, "Internal Wars", civil wars are taking place!
Up todestruction and sharp decline in the economy - more than in
those 40s! And this is not “history” at all. This is real. Real
war. "It's night over Chile."
So what do we have with “summing up”? And just - “don’t.”
“Don’t sum it up just yet - our furthest road is still
ahead." This protracted Moscow performance is far from
there is history, at least the “newest” one. To become history and
receive an already unchanged (Ed: ?) interpretation and assessment of events
should be gone for decades. Lesson: Don't
perestroika-reforms, so that there is no temptation to rewrite
history. But at the same time, justice must be restored,
legality and actual human rights THAT EXISTED WITH US
FOR 70 years. Moreover, "revaluation of all values"
reassessment of the actions of figures of the last ten years in public
opinion has already taken place. The pendulum again changed its position, to
to the other edge. Sobriety and ringing clarity have arrived. Transparency.
Finally, we understand the “material”. Completely understood. Held
"revaluation of all values." It became clear that "democracy"
“human rights”, while military “freedoms” are empty talk, which,
with good intentions, served an evil service, the role of a “Trojan
horse", the modern "Mongol-Tatar yoke". Enveloped, here,
Rus' again. For the new 300 years??
And, nevertheless, current figures, currentevents took place
recent, already Putin, times are clearer, more transparent. And she became
the exploitation of patriotism as another resource is clear. And this
knowledge is, after all, one of the lessons for all of us. Let's study
little by little, that's it!
...Well, he, the “teacher,” the mole, will grade the lesson. which
“digs for a long time,” and in this way he resembles someone. On us. We also "long
“harness”, before setting the “first space”. Fitting then
contrails of jet engines their pages in
world history.
August-September 2001
P.S. What is considered “recent history”? The question, presumably,
remains open. But once again: you are Kasyanov, Ivanov,
Matvienko, Gref and others - all of you are not “history” yet, not even
"newest". Until they "hit". (However, some got stuck!
Chubais with a Xerox box, “writer” Koch “with co-authors”...)
Well, since when could events be considered “newest”? For
ten years before the current one, let’s say. Decide by law
or at the level of the Academy of Sciences. The question is not idle or funny -
so that “at the top” they don’t look “about” (by September)
textbooks and “didn’t get out” then, really, with stupid
proposals.
By the way. Chilean schools have canceled the study of native history
the last thirty years. Timeless time. The centaur galloped along.
P.P.S. Beginning of 2004. This is, indeed, what Kasyanov becamehistory... Gone to...
So what? What does history teach? Really - nothing!
Have our prospects increased? Or, they say, a chance has arisen
economy: growth by so many percent. Enough for you! After the recession
by 90% /and some industries - by 100%!/, with changes
forms, structures of the economy, where the state (we) has almost
there is nothing left, - at the same time, with a decline of 90-100%, talk about
growth?? Not serious! At the noise level such an increase, at the level
errors. The measured value of the order of error is
incorrect assessment. An assessment that has nothing to evaluate. No one and
nothing!
What can we hope for? What is certain?
I hope that the second term of the presidency is the LAST!!
S.V.; Nizhny Novgorod region; October 2005 -> latest edition.
Share your thoughts about the article