Open Letters # 1
Author: Black Cat
Hello, dear SibNews readers!
I’d like to introduce a new column, Open Letters, featuring responses to online comments on articles published in 3aRulem or SibNews. The authors of the articles will respond if they feel it’s necessary. I hope this column will be a worthy continuation of Nemo’s Open Letters tradition. By “worthy,” I mean dignity—not spittle-flecked ranting—and I urge article authors to keep that in mind.
Today I’ll respond to a comment by comrade Maxagor:
http://zx-pk.ru/threads/466-3arulem-pechatnoe-slovo.html?p=
974696&viewfull=1#post974696
about the article “Pentagon. A Retrospective of Its Development” in 3aRulem #23. So, let’s begin:
[Maxagor]
“Exactly, there’s nothing to write about. The funniest thing is that the conflict is one-sided. The whole NedoPC lot couldn’t give a shit about that whole stream of nonsense long ago (this one intended this, that one lied, and that one had such-and-such intentions, and all that pseudo-telepathy—getting inside people’s heads and uncovering intentions that we ourselves are surprised to hear about).”
[BC]
The funniest thing here is attributing some kind of conflict to me :). Personally, I’m not in any conflict with anyone. I’m simply recounting recent history. If anyone thinks I’m in conflict with them, let them notify me immediately by logging in to zx.clan.su, so I’ll know about it too. I’m equally open to talking to anyone, which is more than you can say for NedoPC’s adherents, who tried to get me banned everywhere their hands could reach.
What’s more, back in April 2007, CHRV was even willing to destroy zx.pk.ru, just to shut Black_Cat up. Now tell me, how does that square with Maxagor’s claim that “the whole NedoPC lot couldn’t give a shit”? If that were really true, and not just another lie, NedoPC wouldn’t have tried so hard to shut Black_Cat up; they would simply have ignored him. As you can see, NedoPC is predictably lying yet again!
And by the way, I publicly called on them on zx.pk.ru—way back, about 12!! years ago—to put an end to this stupid confrontation at least twice. But those are precisely the calls they ignored, because they thought they had enough administrative resources to shut Black_Cat up. :) But, as you can see, they still haven’t managed it. :)
[Максагор]
“Plus complete ignorance about ATM—the one persistent accusation about the ‘integral CP/M mode in ATM’ (which the perfectly compatible BaseConf somehow managed just fine without, until they finally hacked it in ‘at numerous requests’) is quite something.
Arguing with nonsense means sinking to the same ‘below the floorboards’ level.
‘Yura, if he’s an engineer, he wouldn’t have blurted out such stupidity as “CP/M mode.” Because in ATM-turbo 2+ you can freely configure the memory dispatcher: set up the pages and palette in the first few dozen bytes of ROM (if you’re too lazy to write a program into ROM with little cursors, menus, whistles and fart noises for choosing different RAM/ROM configurations—after all, you can put any RAM or ROM page into any quarter; you just need to load an 8-byte table into the memory dispatcher), and that’s the mode you’ll get. For example, the “integral mode” for MSX-DOS, which Savelij has already made (but hasn’t released yet, since he’s struggling with FAT16/32 support: MSX-DOS turned out to have FAT12 hardwired by default). And if the author deigns to share the source code, the hardware (both ATM and BaseConf) can easily handle “SymbOS multitasking mode,” too. At the same time, you’ll still be able to exit to TR-DOS, mount images, etc. In other words, there simply is no CP/M mode that “you can’t cut away with Occam’s razor, but you can cut away ZX mode.” It’s all in the programmer’s hands. And that’s the whole “Great Engineer Blackcat.”’
[BC]
Well then, let’s see whose level is below the floorboards :) .
So, this is about the article “Pentagon. A Retrospective on Its Development,” published in 3aRulem No. 23. It’s an article about the history of the architectural development of the Pentagon clone. Note that the article is not about any operating systems that can be used on this clone, but exclusively about the evolution of this clone’s hardware architecture. The PentEvo configuration is mentioned there not because it has anything to do with the development of the Pentagon architecture, but rather the opposite—in connection with the numerous insinuations by the NedoPC group, which tried, through all sorts of lies and rigged claims, to pass off the development of ATM architecture as a Spectrum clone, in particular by bolting an entire Pentagon-1024 v.2.2 onto ATM. So, to dot all the i’s and put an end to NedoPC’s further lies and insinuations, the PentEvo configuration had to be mentioned.
Now let’s get to the substance of Maxagor’s accusation. He claims that since you can load different operating systems on ATM, it’s stupid to mention a “CP/M mode,” and, supposedly, there is no “integral CP/M mode.” Of course, if we were discussing the use of operating systems on ATM, talking about some kind of “CP/M mode” in this context would be strange. But the thing is, the use of operating systems was not discussed in this article at all. The subject was hardware architecture. And precisely in the context of discussing hardware architecture, describing the two hardware operating modes of the ATM computer as “CP/M mode” and “Spectrum mode” is simply archi-professional, since it identifies two incompatible hardware modes that use completely different hardware architectures. :) Spectrum mode uses a Spectrum screen with the screen RAM’s intricately convoluted addressing, whereas CP/M mode uses screens that have absolutely nothing in common with the Spectrum and have linear screen RAM addressing. The name “CP/M mode” itself, however, is merely
tribute to the fact that ATM was originally developed specifically for this OS, and accordingly, the ATM developers designed the screen architecture to meet CP/M requirements—specifically, 40/80 characters per line. Other OSes were adapted to this computer only much later. As you can see, NedoPC is lying again, conflating the real hardware operating modes discussed in the article with some imaginary software modes of various OSes. Then this lie is attributed to Black_Cat, after which Maxagor refutes the existence of the OS modes he himself made up, accusing Black_Cat of inventing them:) Well, that’s a pretty good attempt at demagoguery through conflating concepts, and some technically illiterate zx.pk.ru user might fall for it and become NedoPC’s latest puppet. :)
I’d like to remind you that we are talking about the original ATM computer, not the one corrupted by the NedoPC group. It had two separate operating modes, and switching between them was pointless because it corrupted the image on the screen. This is a very important point, because all of NedoPC’s lies are built on hiding from technically illiterate users the fact that the original ATM had two completely unrelated architectural operating modes. But after МГТФ’s modification, NedoPC removed linear screen addressing in CP/M mode in order to falsify the computer’s architecture and present it as a single architecture with just one architectural operating mode. This was done to present this corrupted ATM as an evolution of the Spectrum, on the grounds that its architecture had supposedly always been unified. And here, once again, lies another lie Maxagor used to mislead technically illiterate zx.pk.ru users. After all, by his logic, if the architecture is unified, then it really is strange to talk about hardware CP/M and Spectrum modes, and therefore mentioning any modes is “utter nonsense.” :)
As you can see, NedoPC is lying again! :) Lying brazenly, right to our faces, assuming that everyone on zx.pk.ru is a dumbass and no one will notice this scam. Though perhaps they’re right about those who don’t want to know the truth. :)
[Максагор]
“When I get to the ‘history’ of the ‘creation’ of ATM in his writings (which I’ve researched thoroughly, and whose most recent part unfolded before my eyes and was carried out in large part by my own hands), this pseudoscientific fiction can only be described as, ‘Oh, so the guys didn’t know!’”
[BC]
The article did not discuss the history of ATM’s creation, since ATM has nothing to do with the development of the Pentagon architecture. The ATM computer was developed at MikroART more than 10 years before NedoPC came into existence, and the NedoPC group has absolutely nothing to do with developing this computer. In other words, another falsification through conflating concepts.
[Максагор]
“Because originally, in 2001–2002, it was me and me alone who started digging up information, hardware and software about ATM wherever I could, from MikroART to users online, and founded the ATM website. Back then I didn’t know Roman or Alone Coder existed, and NedoPC wasn’t just not a project—it wasn’t even an idea for a project. Its current members didn’t know one another either. All of that came much later.”
[BC]
I don't see what any of the above has to do with the article about the Pentagon clone. I really don't know all the details of Maxagor's activities. But I don't particularly dwell on those activities. The only fact that matters here is that NedoPC chose ATM as “the bright future of the Spectrum.” This fact is indisputable, and doesn't depend on whether I know the details of Maxagor's activities or not.
[Maxagor]
“Does he have the right to distort reality and make things up outright, attributing intentions to other people (NedoPC members in particular), and then issuing a verdict and accusation on that basis? I don't think he does. More importantly, this makes us wonder whether everything in the history of the Spectrum that Blackket is offering as a guide is actually true—and whether people might one day come to believe that ‘it happened exactly as it's written here.’”
“P.S. Once again, I'm convinced that the old saying is true: the thief is the one who shouts ‘Stop, thief!’ the loudest, and the one who constantly accuses others of lying is the very person who doesn't mind lying himself.”
[BC]
Why go far looking for “attributing intentions”? Let's “attribute intentions” to Comrade Maxagor together, based on the statements of his quoted above, and determine who the thief he mentioned is. So, here are the results of our analysis of Maxagor's statements: lies, demagoguery involving a bait-and-switch, brazen lies to my face, and cheating—falsification involving a bait-and-switch. As you can see, although NedoPC's mouthpieces shout that they “want to make things better,” somehow what they end up doing is “business as usual” for NedoPC: falsification, demagoguery, lies, bait-and-switch, concealment of facts, silencing dissenters, and brainwashing people to set them against each other. The question is, what is all this for?
You won't believe it, but all this is just to hide from you the fact that CHRV acted unprofessionally and, contrary to the indisputable facts, mistakenly classified ATM as a Spectrum clone. In other words, all of this is purely down to CHRV's selfishness and cowardice: twelve years ago, he was too scared to admit his mistake when I had him backed into a corner. Think about it! How petty and selfish must you be to unleash a war in the community just to hide your own cowardice? What do you think of the moral character of NedoPC's leader? And, as we all know, the fish rots from the head down.
Can we hope that NedoPC will ever stop this war? No. For CHRV and other egotists like him, personal ego comes before everything else! The tactics of people like this are to silence those who know the truth, wait until everyone forgets what the issue was about, and then, through lies, demagoguery, rigging the facts, and concealment, create their own fake “history.” And Maxagor isn't the first to try this: before him, NedoPC's mouthpiece was AloneCoder, and before that, CHRV himself, along with numerous brainwashed followers.
Can anything be done to stop this? Unfortunately, there's no hope that egocentric people will suddenly turn into altruists, concerned for the good of the community, and stop lying and distorting the truth to protect their pathetic egos. Therefore, the only effective way to counter NedoPC's lies is publicity and transparency, so that NedoPC can't keep using its usual tactic of distorting history.
I want to point out that I have nothing against NedoPC's work to support or promote this or that piece of hardware...
platforms, and I am in no way opposed to the ATM computer as such, only to NedoPC’s lies.
ATM is a computer with a hybrid architecture, like, for example, if you bolted a Spectrum mode onto an MSX. Would MSX video modes immediately become a development of the Spectrum architecture? No, of course not, just as the Spectrum screen would not become a development of the MSX architecture! The most we would get from such a combination is a two-in-one hybrid computer—which, essentially, is what we have in the ATM. But that does not make the ATM an evolutionary development of the Spectrum architecture, or, to put it simply, a Spectrum clone. However, thanks to its ability to run Spectrum software, such a hybrid can be classified as a Spectrum-compatible computer, which is what I have been saying for the past 12 years.
I thank Maxagor for raising these questions, which have helped bring NedoPC’s lies into clearer view. But if he thinks the subject has not been covered sufficiently, I am always open to a public dialogue. :) However, I have a proposal specifically for Maxagor on how to put an end to this pointless standoff once and for all. I believe everyone should be given a second chance to set things right. To do that, all that is needed is to acknowledge on his website dedicated to the ATM that the original ATM had two completely unrelated hardware architecture modes—CP/M and Spectrum—and that the modified NedoPC counterfeit computer, tentatively called NedoATM, had only one architecture mode, although that still did not make it a Spectrum clone.
That way, all fans of this computer will be able to get accurate information about its evolutionary development firsthand, from the website dedicated to the ATM. Once this information is posted on the site, any statements made by anyone with the aim of falsifying history will no longer have much meaning. Without support from the site, they will become mere personal opinions that nobody cares about. Thus, the conflict tearing our Spectrum community apart will be resolved positively. I am certainly ready to help with methodological questions about how to present the information on the site.
Many of you know that comrade Maxagor supports communist ideas, and may even be a member of the current CPRF. As we know, communists have always presented themselves as fighters for truth and the people’s welfare. Today, comrade Maxagor is being given such a moment of truth. You will be able to judge the current CPRF by the choice he makes.
So, the choice is yours, comrade Maxagor! If you are a true communist and are genuinely fighting for truth and the people’s welfare—which, in this particular case, means ending the discord in our Spectrum community—you will accept my proposal without reservations. But if you are a fake communist, ready to sell out your Motherland for a voucher, and communist ideals are just hot air to you, then of course you will choose the beer brotherhood with CHRV and come up with a thousand excuses. The moment of truth has arrived! Make your choice, comrade Maxagor! :)
You can find me at
http://zx.clan.su/forum/
or on ZX&Nibiru in Telegram:
https://t.me/joinchat/FnSx4EPOYbB_uqA6dd2dnA
Share your thoughts about the article