Pisism — The PC vs Amiga Debate

Modern #09

Pisism

(C) The Left

Greetings once again, most esteemed readers!

A letter from SPIDER has arrived at the newspaper’s editorial office, and I will reply to it.

S: You’re wrong about SoundBlasters! A standard 16-bit SoundBlaster has 22 channels (11 are mixed into the left channel and 11 into the right to produce stereo).

L: The point remains the same!!! No matter how many channels you have, they are all mixed down to two in the end, and mixing inevitably introduces errors (see MODERN 8).

S: But the Amiga really does have four channels, and it can play four samples simultaneously, compared with 22 samples on a SoundBlaster.

L: What 22 samples are you talking about! The 22 samples are mixed into two! Consequently, two samples play on an IBM, while four play on an Amiga. And there are also trackers on the Amiga that let you write music with far more than 22 channels, for example: Actomed — 64 channels, DJ Buster — channels, Symphony — channels (these are just the ones I know about!).

S: By the way, sound on the Amiga is digital too, so you can’t compare it with a line on an oscilloscope screen (which is analog); its quality depends on the bit depth.

L: Sound is digital on any computer. But we’re not talking about the quality of a sample; we’re talking about distortion when it is played back. If a four-channel tune is playing on the Amiga, the distortion is zero. On an IBM, it is clearly greater than zero...

S: The most widespread sound on PCs is 16-bit. 32-bit sound did not become widespread, but 64-bit sound cards with wavetable synthesis are currently the most popular, allowing sounds from different musical instruments to be reproduced with absolute accuracy.

L: The point remains the same — two channels, mathematical mixing... Errors are inevitable.

S: As for the frequency, 44 kHz is used when recording CDs. I think that’s enough, considering that most people can’t hear sounds above 19 kHz, and most amplifiers don’t reproduce frequencies above 22 kHz.

L: Unless you take into account that this sound “sometimes” also has to be mixed.

S: As for the price, a PC that is more powerful and better equipped than an Amiga costs less.

L: PC and power are concepts from different fields. What annoys me is that nothing on a PC can be perfect! Something will always let you down: if the graphics are fast, they’re blocky; if the resolution is high, they’re jerky! And remember that PC users and Amiga users have different ideas about smoothness! You’re simply not used to smooth movement (just look at the movement of a mouse pointer on a PC), and you’ll never understand what real smoothness is! At the same time, don’t forget that all sorts of superb add-ons are sold for the Amiga too. They may cost a little more (but not much), yet their quality is perfect, and the software won’t ask you to replace your processor or graphics card, or buy another 64 megabytes of memory, a month later... Besides, everything made for the PC is one big animation, gobbling up unimaginable amounts of memory, which again means a lot of expense...

S: I wouldn’t advise writing about video cards here; I already have plenty of arguments in favour of the PC.

L: Only if you say Microsoft has developed a new animation format, but to play it you need a brand-new graphics card for $...

S: Say what you like, progress is a powerful thing, and the Amiga has remained at the level of ’93.

L: New and newer accelerators for the Amiga are appearing: 3D accelerators, graphics cards, music add-ons. At the same time, new software doesn’t make them mandatory; you won’t see a message in a new game saying “PowerPC processor needed” or anything like that. Amiga add-ons are developing, while the Amiga itself no longer needs modification, because it was free of all sorts of “bugs” from the outset.

I’m not a blind fan at all; I can see the Amiga’s shortcomings too. For example, programmers don’t squeeze every possibility out of this machine. They’re too lazy to come up with new, faster algorithms; they want to achieve speed only through hardware and treat the software side as secondary.

But that’s the fault of people, not the computer.

The word PC makes me think of “POP MUSIC”. Or of “PISISM”. Whichever you prefer.

Share your thoughts about the article